Table 1: List of malaria vaccines
|
Type of Vaccines |
Name: Compositions |
Beneficial / Limitations |
|
Pre-erythrocytic vaccines |
1. RTS,S/AS01E ·
Adenovirus (Ad35) vectored
circumsporozoite (CS) protein in prime boost with RTS,S/AS01E ·
Multiple epitope constructs
(ME-TRAP); a pre-erythrocytic fusion antigen consisting of 17 B-cell, CD4+,
CD8+ T cell epitopes of 6 Pf antigens fused to the T9/96 allele of TRAP
(Thrombospondin related adhesion protein) |
·
Only the vaccine in Phase 3
clinical trial ·
Low efficacy but decreases
mortality |
|
2. AdCh63/MVA ME-TRAP ·
Simian Adenovirus (Ad35) encoding
ME-TRAP boosted with modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA) |
·
Long lasting CD8+ T cell
responses |
|
|
3. Polyepitope DNA EP1300 ·
DNA vaccine includes multiple
epitopes with linker sequences from four pre-erythrocytic antigens CS,
SSP2/TRAP, liver stage antigen-1 (LSA-1) and Exported protein-1 (EP-1) |
·
Immunogenicity is not enhanced in
human as compared to animals |
|
|
4. PfSPZ ·
Metabolically active
non-replicating malaria sporozoite vaccine (Pf sporozoites prepared by
thawing from liquid nitrogen) |
·
Not protective but need to
revised in terms of dose and route of administration |
|
|
5. Genetically Attenuated sporozoites-GAS |
·
Safe and immunogenic |
|
|
6. FP9 CS/MVA CS ·
Attenuated fowl pox strain (FP9)
expressing CS protein boosted with MVA coding CS protein |
·
Didn’t boost the T-cell response |
|
|
7. DNA CS/MVA CS ·
Plasmid DNA encoding CS protein
replace fowl pox strain (FP9) boosted with MVA coding CS protein |
·
Modest T-cell response |
|
|
8. RTS,S/AS02 + MVA CS ·
Boosting RTS,S/AS02 with MVA
encoding CS |
·
Greater CMI response ·
|
|
|
9. CS DNA Immunization or VCL-2510 ·
Gene for full length CS protein
in Plasmid DNA |
·
No anti-CS antibodies |
|
|
10. MUST DO5 ·
Multi-Stage DNA vaccine operation
5 antigens ·
5 antigens; CS, SSP2/TRAP, LSA-1,
LSA-3 and EP-1 adjuvanted with GM-CSF (Granulocyte Macrophage colony
stimulating factor) |
·
No efficacy |
|
|
11. DNA CS / RTS,S/AS02 ·
DNA vaccine VCL-2510 containing
full length CS gene and adjuvanted with RTS,S/AS02 |
·
No significant improvement than
using alone |
|
|
12. RTS,S/AS02 TRAP ·
Combination of CS with TRAP |
·
Improve efficacy |
|
|
13. HepB Core Ag CS VLP ·
Also called ICC-1132 or
Malariavax ·
Hepatis B core antigen modified
to include B-cell and 2 CD4+ epitopes of CS protein |
·
No efficacy to sporozoites |
|
|
14. PfCS102 ·
Chemically synthesized Pf CS
protein with C-terminus (Amino acids 282-383) |
·
Don’t reduce parasitemia |
|
|
15. FP9/MVA polyprotein ·
Prime Boosting with FP9 and MVA
viruses with six antigens polyprotein (STARP, TRAP, LSA-1, LSA-3, Pfs16 and
EP-1) |
·
Low efficacy with sporozoite challenge |
|
|
16. FMP011/AS01B ·
LAS-1 E. coli expressed
evaluated with AS01B and AS02A |
·
Associated with acute coronary
syndrome |
|
|
|
||
|
Blood Stage (Erythrocytic)
vaccines |
1. AdCh63/MVA MSP-1 ·
Pf Merozoite Surface Protein-1
(MSP-1) expressed and boosted with AdCh63 and MVA vectors |
·
Low IgG response |
|
2. FMP010/AS01B ·
E. coli expressing FVO allele 42kD C terminus of MSP-1 and
adjuvants AS01B |
·
Good immunogenicity but
inadequate clinical efficacy |
|
|
3. FMP2.1/AS02A ·
FMP2.1, in which E. coli
expressed Apical membrane antigen (AMA-1) and adjuvant AS02A |
·
Strong Th-2 biased response |
|
|
4. FMP2.1/AS01B ·
FMP2.1, in which E. coli
expressed Apical membrane antigen (AMA-1) and adjuvant AS01B |
·
Adverse effect (rashes after 18
days of vaccination) |
|
|
5. AMA-C1/Alhydrogel + CPG 7909 ·
Pichia pastoris expressed Apical membrane antigen (AMA-1) with both
FVO and 3D7 strains and adjuvants Alhydrogel + CPG 7909 |
·
Reduction of hemoglobin ·
|
|
|
6. AdCh63 AMA-1/MVA AMA-1 ·
Apical membrane antigen-1 (AMA-1)
expressed and boosted with AdCh63 and MVA vectors |
·
CD4+ responses are higher than
CD8+ response |
|
|
7. EBA175RII ·
Erythrocyte binding antigen (EBA)
in merozoites and highly conserved region of Pf |
·
Safe and immunogenic |
|
|
8. SERA5 ·
Blood stage antigen in
trophozoites and schizonts (SE36 expressed in E. coli acts as fragment
of SERA5 antigen) |
·
Safe and 100% seroconversion |
|
|
9. BSAM-2/Alhydrogel +CPG ·
combination vaccine including MSP1 and
AMA1 components. It contains a mixture of recombinant proteins with equal
parts P. pastoris expressing FVO and
3D7 strains of AMA1 and E. coli expressing the FVO and 3D7 strains of MSP1. |
·
Under evaluation |
|
|
10. JAIVAC ·
This combination vaccine consists of MSP1
and EBA175, each of which is an E. coli expressed recombinant protein adjuvanted with Montanide
ISA 720 |
·
Synergistic effects |
|
|
11. GMZ2 ·
L. lactis expressed recombinant
fusion protein of glutamate rich protein (GLURP) and MSP-3 adjuvanted with
Al(OH)3 |
·
Acceptable safety ·
Both IgG and memory B cell
response |
|
|
12. Combination B (RESA, MSP-1, MSP-2) 13. FMP1/AS02A 14. MSP-1-C1/AlOH/AlOH + CPG 15. MSP2-C1/ISA720 16. AMA1-C1/ISA720 17. AMA-FVO 18. PfCP2.9 |
·
Already terminated (No succeed) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Gametocyte (Transmission
Blocking) Vaccines |
1. Pfs25 ·
Ookinete surface protein Pfs25 ·
The antigen preparations including ookinete surface protein Pfs25, and the gametocyte
antigens Pfs48/45 and Pfs230 are used in the TBV vaccines. Pfs25 was the first antigen to progress clinically but the reactogenicity
was found to be very low. |
·
Low reactogenicity |
|
2. Pfs48/45 and Pfs230 ·
Contain the gametocyte antigens
Pfs48/45 and Pfs230 |
·
Low reactogenicity |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Combined Vaccines |
1. NMRC-M3V-D/Ad-PfCA Prime/Boost and NMRC-M3V-Ad-PfCA ·
DNA based vaccine containing CS
antigen with AMA-1 antigen boosted with Adenovirus-5-vectors |
·
Increase CD8+ T cell response but
no sterile protection |
|
2. CS AMA1 Virosomes ·
Synthetic peptide vaccines ·
Phosphatidylethanolamine (PE)
conjugates on the surface of immunopotentiating reconstituted influenza
virosomes (PEV301 and PEV302) |
·
No sterile protection |
|
|
3. SPf66 ·
Synthetic polypeptide vaccine
consisting of CS and merozoites protein1 (MSP1) epitopes adjuvanted with alum |
·
Low vaccine efficacy |
|
|
4. RTS,S/AS02 (CS) and FMP-1/AS02 (MSP1) ·
Mixing RTS,S/AS02 (CS) and
FMP-1/AS02 (MSP1) with both CS and MSP1 antigens |
·
FMP1 gave no protection in the
challenge model |
|
|
|
|
|
|
P. vivax Vaccines |
1. PvCSP ·
Circumsporozoite protein from P.
vivax |
·
Under clinical trails |
|
2. ChAd63-MVA PvDBP RII and PvDBP RII/GLA-SE ·
Extracellular, cysteine-rich
region II (P. vivax Duffy-binding protein; PvDBP_RII) |
·
Under clinical trails |
|